All posts by Chris M. Dickson

An unexpected conclusion to the Croco-League

Croco-Puzzle logoThis follows on from yesterday’s discussion of, among other topics, “B” teams in the Croco-League online team puzzle competition.

As it turns out, the second season of the Croco-League went down to the final match day, with the top two teams facing each other in the final week, with the winner of the match earning the championship. The two top teams are “tba”, the first season champions, and the Czech Team – and, after yesterday’s posts, you can tell which of the two I prefer.

I like the thought of there being a team with the commonality of representing the Czech Republic. (I’m less interested in playing against a second or third Czech Republic team, though; I’d rather play against the best that a smaller, more specific area has to offer, whether it’s – say – the whole of Bohemia, the town of Brno, or even just a particular western suburb of Prague.) There may be some strong commonality or bond between the members of “tba”, other than that all the team’s members are extremely good at puzzles, but they don’t make it clear.

One of the joys of the Croco-League is the “Wiedergabe” option that acts as a sort of puzzle “Match of the Day”, and the eminently sensible decision has been taken to make the highlights for the last round every game from this title decider.

Take a look at the Domino puzzle within the match, and notice that when lines are being deleted around the centre of the “tba” player’s side at around 0:55-1:00, another line is unexpectedly deleted in the top-left corner. The absence of this line causes the “tba” player’s solution to be incorrect, which causes them to lose the puzzle, which causes them to draw the match, which causes them to lose the title.

It has been ruled that the unexpected deletion of the line in the top-left was due to an inexplicable applet error, rather than a player mishap or a mouseslip. It’s worrying that such applet errors could happen, but it does seem extremely unlikely that someone could choose to delete lines in two completely different parts of the applet at the same time, and the ruling has been made by someone who is uniquely well-placed to know whether the player or the applet really is to blame.

Consequently that puzzle (or, possibly, the whole match of 12 puzzles) will be replayed and the fate of the championship remains inconclusive. More news as it becomes available.

⁂

Not your cup of tea? In London, registration closes on Friday for a new season of Street Wars, a water-based-weapon-only assassination game running across zones 1-4 over the whole of June. Looks quite intense.

The best of the rest

Ornate letter BSometimes issues crop up in the real world with unexpected relevance in the world of puzzle competitions as well. The week before last, the chairman of the Football Association, Greg Dyke, released an England Commission report, regarding supporting the number of English players involved in the game at a high level, hoping to boost the chances of the English national team down the line. The aspect of this which has most caught people’s attention is the proposal to permit clubs to enter second (or “B”) teams into the existing structure. The proposals have largely proven unpopular. However, the world of puzzle competitions has faced similar issues in the past.

B teams at the World Puzzle Championship

Some years, the World Puzzle Championships have permitted nations to enter “B” (and, very occasionally, “C”) teams as well. Officially, the individual ranking order only includes the (up to) four designated “A” team members per country, and the team ranking order only includes “A” teams with four members; if a country enters fewer than four members, they will get individual rankings, but the country will not get a team ranking.

Unofficial ranking orders are also produced, ranking “A” team members alongside “B” team members and sometimes (see, e.g., Beijing 2013) even guests as well. Only “A” team members are eligible to take part in play-off competitions held as grand finals. Sometimes it happens that a non-“A”-team member performs well enough that they would have made the play-offs and are excluded from participation, but there is no outcry against this practice. The theoretical issue comes if a non-“A”-team member outperforms all the “A”-team members and yet still cannot enter the playoffs; people seem reasonably content that this is likely to be only a theoretical issue, sufficiently unlikely to crop up (and risk asking questions about the validity of that year’s championship title) in practice.

Consensus of opinion seems to be in favour of “B” teams; again looking at Beijing 2013, a majority of the most successful nations sent whole “B” teams, and it may well be that many of the “United Nations” teams are made up of incomplete “B” teams. At one point, the World Puzzle Federation board never reached a conclusion on the issue and left it to individual championship organisers whether or not to accept “B” teams; the principle of “B” team and guest participants paying a slight surcharge to subsidise “A” team participation, particularly from “A” teams whose members would otherwise not be able to afford to participate, seems to have proven popular. (Personally, I fully support it.)

B teams in the Croco-League

The issue of “B” teams also appears in the Croco-League online team puzzle competition, as previously discussed. Here, teams can choose to name themselves whatever they like, and some teams choose to name themselves as being the second team of another, established, team in the league. There is no formal tie between the two teams; it’s not possible for a “B” team to send players to the “A” team or vice versa, other than through the usual routes which (largely) only permit players to leave established teams between seasons.

It’s probably fair to compare this to the World Puzzle Championship tradition. It’s also probably fair to say that the Croco-League doesn’t just draw on the tradition of association football leagues, it draws on the tradition of the German league system in particular, which has long featured clubs’ reserve teams at a reasonably high level.

Several of the Croco-Puzzle teams draw their membership from whole countries and name their team accordingly, which is fun. As so many of the site’s users come from Germany, naturally enough, many of the teams draw their membership from specific parts of Germany and name their team accordingly, which is also fun. When there are more solvers from a non-German country than can fit in a single team, some communities have tended to organise themselves into “A” and “B” teams, whereas the UK tradition so far has been to have a Northern UK team and a Southern UK team. (Even then, the distinguishing line is whether someone feels Northern or not, for any other boundary would effectively be as vague and arbitrary – people move, people are not distributed evenly around the UK, and so on.)

I feel strongly that, as much as I support “B” teams in the World Puzzle Championships, I oppose “B” teams in the Croco-League. It’s fun to feel like you’re competing against the best that a country, or a region, has to offer; it’s much more meaningful to feel like you’re competing against the best that a small locality has to offer than to feel like you’re competing against the second (or third, etc.) best that a larger area has to offer.

It’s not for me to tell other communities how to organise their teams, but I definitely have a strong preference for a geographical split. After all, in the World Puzzle Championship, you (barring velvet revolutions and independence referenda) can’t choose which country you represent; in the Croco-League, it’s easy to start a new, more tightly-focused team.

Perhaps my preference for there being many teams with tight geographic bases is a direct reflection of my familiarity with the English football league tradition rather than the German one. I am strongly against the proposal for “B” teams in the English football leagues, so perhaps it is not surprising that I have counterpart feelings about the Croco-League.

Breakout Manchester

Breakout Manchester logoManchester is set to join London and Bristol as a city with two different exit game sites with the launch of Breakout Manchester. The web site’s “Rooms” page suggests that the first room opened on Saturday 17th May, which seems to be as convincing a claim for an opening date as any, especially as one of their Tweets suggests that they had their first team win on Sunday 18th May. The site’s booking system suggests that bookings are available from Tuesday 20th May onwards; there’s a phone number quoted on the site if you wanted to confirm a booking for the very near future. The off-peak price is particularly attractive.

The site has a really exciting web presence, suggesting that while only one game is open at the moment, there are plans to add three more. I especially like the look of the second game, set to open in June, entitled Madchester. The description reads:

Manchester is famous for many things: football, relentless rain, musicians and bands such as the Smiths, Stone Roses and Oasis, Coronation Street, incredible night clubs such as the Hacienda, The Warehouse Project and Sankeys and artists such as LS Lowry. But what links all these things? What is Manchester trying to hide? This room may reveal the truth….

This sounds like a really distinctive and exciting prospect; the concept of trying to incorporate some local flavour into an exit room would provide a reason to travel from afar to play, and Manchester has more flavour to draw from than most locations. It’s not clear whether the game will be about the 24 Hour Party People sort of Madchester, but the prospect of it makes you want to step on to this one so you can have your melon twisted.

Unusually, there is one factor which might, under certain circumstances, make you want to hold off playing until the second room opens. The first room is John Monroe’s Detective Office, and it’s the same room that Mazebase have already installed at HintHunt in London and at Puzzlair in Bristol. If you’ve played it at either of those locations, you might well not be nearly as surprised by it in Manchester. However, both of these are quite a hike from Manchester; if you haven’t played it before, it’s a great game and you’re in for a treat.

Private e-mail discussion suggests that the proprietors have investigated and plenty of the other UK sites, which breeds confidence. Time will tell if the proprietors have learnt from their extensive research and are able to put the theory into practice for their original rooms; more news about these additional rooms as it becomes available.

Approaches to difficulty in exit games

GameCamp logoYesterday, at GameCamp in London, there was a talk on the exit game phenomenon given by Adrian Hon. It’s not clear what GameCamp etiquette is, whether what gets said at GameCamp stays at GameCamp, whether things can be reported under the Chatham House Rule, or whether there can be wider reports, but it would be great to hear more from the event. Failing that, Adrian discussed the genre towards the end of episode 41 of “The Cultures” podcast.

Some exit games take the approach that they will be very generous with the distribution of hints to their players, even making it clear that this is the policy right at the outset, in the discussion before players enter the room. As this was the approach taken by the first exit room site to open in the UK, this may well be the dominant approach nationally.

By contrast, there are other sites which offer some games where few or no clues are offered. The pitfall there is either that you set the difficulty level relatively high and have no or very few people crack the room, or you set the difficulty level relatively low and risk having people finish the game in less than half the permitted time, which can be something of a flat ending. There are plenty of other solutions, especially if players are prepared to enjoy the possibility of partial credit for solving some, but not all, of the game, but these appear to be less frequent.

Incidentally, the “deliberately very few winners” approach is the one taken by many of the games offered by SCRAP, considered the originators of the genre, among other operators. Befitting the Japanese origins of the “Nintendo hard” stereotype, as an example, their “What is the Real Escape Game?” page talks of a 2% success rate, and their Flickr photostream has a couple of photos of ongoing scoreboards suggesting victory rates not much higher than that. (Anecdotally, more recent games suggest an easing of standards to around 10%.) This site is not yet aware of any UK exit games that take quite such an extreme approach.

The issue of difficulty of exit games is an open one; there appears not to be a consensus on a single correct approach. As different players want to face different challenges, this variety of approaches may well be a good thing for the world. The difficulty is to match potential players up to the right game for them. This web site will do whatever it can to help in this regard.

The Keyhunter site in Birmingham takes a particularly interesting approach in this regard; it advertises its three games as having different levels of difficulty, and advertises its teams successes on social media not only in terms of the time they took but also by how many clues were needed. If you want the added challenge of completing an exit room and having “with 0 hints used” decorating your performance, perhaps Keyhunter might be the right site for you. There may well be other games that offer the same option and this site will make it clear when it’s available.

How good are you at puzzles?

Generic logistic curveIn some regards, “How good are you at puzzles?” is as broad a question as “How good are you at schoolwork?”. As much as you might be strong at mathematics, reasonable at physics, moderate at Ancient Greek and terrible at metalwork, someone could be brilliant at crosswords, very good at sudoku, moderate at logic puzzles and weak at twisty mechanical puzzles, say.

Nevertheless, it’s a question that sometimes gets asked when you say that you enjoy puzzles – a notion that, by itself, may be alien to many. You can tell people that you have done so well at this particular competition, but there is nothing with the immediacy, interoperability and cultural familiarity of, say, a golf handicap, a martial arts belt colour or a chess rating. (And even then, likely each of those has their own nuances.) Even a claim like “I’ve been part of a team at the World Puzzle Championship” means something rather different if you had to finish in the top four out of just six entrants to qualify for the UK team, as was the case for me back in 2000, than if you are facing a field of dozens of experienced competitors, as is now the case. (And the standard at the World Puzzle Championship has got so much higher over the years…)

As well as the variety of team and individual competitions, some with prizes, and the 40+ different types of puzzles to play, another of the main reasons why I care about the Croco-Puzzle web site so much is that it lets you earn a meaningful rating that reflects your performance at the puzzles it offers.

It can go further than that, giving you meaningful separate ratings for each of the 40+ types of puzzle that are available. So when a Masyu variant appeared in DASH 6 – about which we can talk now, as Minneapolis will have finished their recast! – and I grumbled that I was lousy at Masyu, I can tell you just how lousy I am at them: a rating of 917, compared to an overall rating of 1357. Believe me, even the 1357 is not much to be proud about.

Accordingly, I have added another couple of sections to the Croco-Puzzle walkthrough, explaining how to play other examples of the daily puzzles that the site offers (specifically, the “freeform” puzzles alongside the applet-style puzzles) and an explanation of the site’s ratings and ranking system.

The metagame of playing the daily puzzles to improve my ratings (and hence, eventually, my ranking) has kept me coming back to Croco-Puzzle for years, making it my site of choice for daily culture-free language-neutral online puzzles. The German language interface can be off-putting, hence I’ve produced the English-language walkthrough. The site keeps getting better and better, with the recent Croco-Marathon contest offering access to accessible examples of each of the 40 types of puzzle on which to practice your skills. I offer the site my highest recommendation.

Weekend round-up

US Sudoku Team logoTechnically this is the US Sudoku Championship logo rather than the US Puzzle Championship one, but it’s always been a beauty. This weekend’s highlight is the US Puzzle Championship, a 2½-hour online language-free culture-neutral puzzle contest, where participation is open to entrants around the world. You can still register to take part; once you’ve logged in, the instruction booklet is available. Download the puzzles in advance; the password will be revealed at 6pm UK time on Saturday 17th and you have until 8:30pm UK time to submit your answers in order to score as many points as possible.

It’s worth reflecting at this point that as recently as 2010, the UK puzzle season was the US Puzzle Championship – and, if you didn’t qualify for the World Championship, that was it. 2010 was a pivotal year with the launch of the UK Puzzle Association and also Logic Masters India bringing frequent tests; 2011 saw the start of the UK Puzzle Championship and so much has followed since. The US Puzzle Championship is quite a traditional event, what with its fixed timeslot; it is clearly aimed to find the best competitors for the phenomenally successful US team for the WPC and sets its difficulty accordingly. If you’d like to know more, this site recommends Dr. Thomas Snyder’s nine-part Better Know the USPC series from 2011.

Let’s round up the latest exit game news as well:

  • In Edinburgh, Escape opened today, and this site has the joy of turning their red “opening soon!” map dot to a glorious yellow.
  • In Manchester, Make A Break have announced good news: they have proved popular enough to extend their opening hours at weekends.
  • In London, HintHunt also have good news to announce: they are opening a second Zen Room from 1st June; they will be able to host five games at once, making them the biggest single site at the moment. They are fully booked up at weekends until mid-July, other than for this second Zen Room, so this is a very rare weekend opportunity to play.
  • However, unfortunately, it’s not all good news; Escape Hunt have announced that their London opening will be delayed until late August. Good things come to those who wait!

Opening in Leeds on Monday: Tick Tock Unlock

"Tick Tock Unlock" logoThis site has previously featured a preview of Tick Tock Unlock, an exit game coming to Leeds very soon. Their Facebook site suggests that a booking has already been made for May 19th, and the opening date has been confirmed on Twitter, which is sufficiently convincing to merit a place on The Timeline and the exit game details page. However, the web site suggests that bookings are currently available from Wednesday 21st May onwards, so it may well be that they have plans for the rest of Monday and Tuesday.

There have been some gorgeous photos added to their Facebook site recently; it’s well worth clicking through to see the rest of the album. The details within the room look atmospheric and delightful. The photos say that “You can step into the professor’s office but the leaving will not be so easy…” Private e-mail reveals a little more that can be exclusively revealed. The game is entitled Blueprint and here’s its background:

“Conspiracy theorist and history professor, James Watson, has vanished under mysterious circumstances. He was once considered the bright star of academia before he uncovered the web of criminal reality lurking in plain sight. What started as a drive to unmask the criminals very quickly took over his life. His obsession, which led many to call him delusional, consumed him; some even questioned his sanity. That is, until he vanished without a trace. If you are reading this, you already know too much and they are coming after you next.

You are the last remaining hope to uncover the truth from his delusions. Solve the mystery, escape in sixty minutes – Tick Tock Unlock.”

Extremely promising and tantalisingly close!

MUMS: the word

Melbourne University Maths (and Stats) Society logoThis site has news from three exit game sites, two of which have not yet been mentioned before, all of which is nearly fit for publication but is just not quite there yet. Tease-y tease tease.

So, instead, follow-up to discussion two weeks ago of the Australian puzzle hunt tradition. The Melbourne University Mathematics and Statistics Society, whose logo is above, ran their annual puzzle hunt in early May. This was their eleventh hunt, or the tenth anniversary of the first; the first hunt’s co-ordination is credited to one Julian Assange, vice-president of the society at the time. Quite a legacy.

The 2014 hunt looks likely to be judged extremely favourably by history. There were 192 teams on the scoreboard, doubtless plenty of others who failed to trouble the scorers, and there has been an estimate of over 860 participants all told. That’s a huge achievement! It’s not a competition to have the biggest puzzle hunt; thanks go to all hunt organisers, whether their event is large or small. Nevertheless, the MUMS event is one of the world’s great hunts. (Particularly interesting is the comment “It’s human to want to be part of something bigger than ourselves. And man! This is big! Go puzzle hunt legacy!” at the bottom of page 11. Absolutely agreed, MUMS; with that in mind, consider yourselves firmly pointed in the direction of DASH and Puzzled Pint…)

This year there is even a behind-the-scenes document that is a must-read, a particularly fine example of the type. One cute sidenote is that one participant was cryptic crossword creator, writer and media personality David Astle, who blogged about his experience and very entertainingly discussed it on his radio show (well worth a listen: go about 6’45” through, and there’s three minutes about the hunt). Astle also played a role as dictionary expert on Letters and Numbers, which might effectively make him the Australian Susie Dent.

Congratulations to Wild Goldfish: Lumber Support, the winning team, and to every other team happy with their record of success. A particular tip of the hat to the tenth-placed ManMaths team, solving all 20 puzzles plus the meta, who derive their name from mathematics in Manchester – the one in the UK! – and are heavily associated with the marvellous monthly Puzzlebomb.

Coming soon to Edinburgh: Escape

Escape logoDespite recently looking forward to future exit game launches, this one came as a surprise! Two weeks ago, this site reported on the Can You Escape? Indiegogo project to open a room in Edinburgh. That Indiegogo is continuing apace, but one of the dangers of a crowdfunded project is that other projects can beat them to the punch, and Can You Escape? clearly will not be the first exit game to launch in Edinbugh; a site called Escape will beat them to it, by opening on Friday 16th May.

The location is only a few hundred metres from Edinburgh’s famous Princes Street; when Edinburgh’s trams open at the end of the month, the “West End – Princes Street” stop will probably be the closest. The exit game’s web site was launched on Thursday and I would describe the ambiance as elegant. (The lower-case-“e”-as-a-maze logo is particularly smart.) There’s a heavier focus on corporate team building than is the case for several other sites; it’s a distinctive angle to take and may well work out well, particularly in such a business-focused city as Edinburgh. Even the location of the game itself is within the Citibase building.

However, it’s not just a game for businesses; families and groups of friends are as welcome here as they are at every other exit game up and down the land. Edinburgh is a great tourist destination as well and the timing is very good, giving a couple of months to bed down before festival season starts. There are two one-hour games, referred to as “The Light Room” and “The Dark Room”; the pricing is simple, a flat £60 per team of two-to-five, plus a £2 booking fee.

The list of exit games and timeline have been updated; it has also been a delight to change the size of the map so that it stretches further north. This site wishes Escape well and looks forward to having more to report from it soon!

What’s happening this weekend

weekly calendarSo there have been a couple of preview posts recently, but this weekend is as busy as any yet seen by this site.

Are you in Norwich? The Knightmare Convention, discussing one of the most beloved children’s puzzle shows in UK TV history, starts today, featuring a hunt very late on Saturday night, which promises to be distressingly cool.

Are you in Wrexham? Saturday sees the Silent State hunt through the town, as part of the European Opera Day celebrations. Tickets are still available, with the ticket page promising “a mixture of puzzles, music, intrigue and theatrical happenings”. Even if the puzzles were dialled down fairly low, this would still promise to be distressingly cool.

Are you in London? If murder mystery is your thing (and if it isn’t, you’re probably lost) then “get ready to explore, puzzle and pun your way through the streets of London” with a door in a wall‘s The Diplomatic Corpse hunt. Tickets are £30 per head for a 4½-hour team game, though twentysomethinglondon have a discount code for Tuesdays. Early reviews seem as positive as you would hope for an event that promises to be distressingly cool.

If any readers go to any of the above, this site would be delighted to feature reviews or reports from any of these events; please send e-mail to the usual address.

Are you far from Wrexham, Norwich and London? It could still be a big weekend! Solvers from all nations are invited to take the two-hour UK Sudoku Championship paper online between now and Monday night – and, if that’s not enough, the World Puzzle Federation’s Sudoku Grand Prix features 90 minutes of puzzles from Japan this weekend. Alternatively, Logic Masters Germany feature the 2½-hour online qualification round of the German puzzle championship this weekend; instructions are available in English, and it’s good practice for the US and UK counterpart puzzle contests of the same length over the next two weekends.