Tag Archives: uk

The League Table: end of May 2014

Picture of a generic trophyThis is the second installment of an occasional feature to act as a status report on the exit games in the UK. On its own it means little, but repeated sufficiently many times it could be the basis of a survey of growth over time.

Exit Game sites known to have opened in the UK/Ireland: 12/1
Exit Game sites known to be open in the UK/Ireland: 11/1
Exit Game sites known to have closed temporarily in the UK/Ireland: 1/0
Exit Game sites known to have closed permanently in the UK/Ireland: 0/0
Exit Game sites known to be under construction in the UK/Ireland: 3/0
Exit Game sites less confidently known to be under construction in the UK/Ireland: 3/0

Site name Number of exit rooms Number of different games Number of TripAdvisor reviews Number of 5/5 TripAdvisor reviews Local TripAdvisor ranking
Breakout Manchester 1 1 4 4 62
clueQuest 3 2 426 411 1
Cipher 1 1 – – –
Cryptopia 1 1 24 21 9
Escape 2 1 7 7 81
ESCAP3D 1 1 73 62 3
Ex(c)iting Game 2 2 17 12 22
HintHunt 5 2 805 748 3
Keyhunter 3 3 38 25 6
Make A Break 1 1 22 15 12
Tick Tock Unlock 1 1 9 9 19
Puzzlair 2 2 36 36 2
XIT 4 4 3 2 101

This needs to be taken with a heavy pinch of salt. This site supports all the exit games that exist and will not make claims that any particular one is superior to any other particular one. Please note that the TripAdvisor rankings represent a wide variety of locations and cannot be directly compared against each other. In fact, it’s probably pushing it even to compare the tripAdvisor rankings of two exit game sites in the same city. One site has received four ratings over the course of the month, all 5/5, and has promptly dropped six places within its city. Seems strange; what more might it do?

Updating our estimate as to how many people have played an exit game in the UK or Ireland, we will revise our prior estimate for the number of people by the end of April 2014 up to 34,000 and the estimate for the number of people by the end of May 2014 up to 39,000. (As usual, this is not a confident estimate, but should be correct to within a factor of three.) The expansion of HintHunt from four rooms to five at the start of June is likely to have a reasonably large effect in future months.

Hidden Cash around the UK

A wad of banknotes from the "Hidden Cash UK" Twitter accountIn the last week, a successful property speculator has been hiding envelopes with moderate quantities of cash around cities near the west coast of the United States, posting pictures of the locations and not-very-cryptic clues to their whereabouts to their Twitter account. There is something of a “pay it forward” motif, though of course this cannot be enforced. Apparently it has spawned imitators; most relevantly for us, Hidden Cash UK has made three drops in the North in two days.

There are definitely possibilities here. As there have been many imitators already, there’s no reason why there couldn’t be more to come: there’s got to be room for a Hidden Cash GB, a Hidden Cash Ireland, a Hidden Cash London and so on. Some would consider a couple of hundred pounds a very adequate investment for thousands, or tens of thousands, of involved followers within a couple of days. If someone were to distribute Hidden Cash coincidentally outside their exit game site, then perhaps the site could attract the attention of those looking for it who are likely to be favourably inclined, though possibly unimpressed by a lack of subtlety. (Hiding the cash inside an exit game and charging people to play it might well be considered a bit cheek, though you might still get away with it.)

This probably has the hallmarks of being a half-a-week’s wonder on Twitter in its current form, but if the mainstream media decide to run with it then perhaps there’s a few weeks, or a few months in it. (Maybe more.) This is far from original, of course; Tom Scott and Dan W. ran Advent Locker in December 2012, which is similar but used prizes in Amazon Lockers, and you know that this site will take any opportunity it gets to link to the wonderful story of the newspapers’ own Treasure Hunt Riots, a little over a century earlier. (Also a salutary reminder of the potential dangers of such things. Dan and Tom did nothing more ill-willed than having their Christmas Eve prize be a good old festive RickRoll, but not all patrons need be so benign.)

Treasure hunts themselves are far older; the parallels to geocaching are obvious, and that is so well-known that it need not be explained. Arguably Hidden Cash has a closer connection to its GPS-less, clue-heavier predecessor, letterboxing, which has been dated back to 1854.

There has to be something exciting and relevant to do while Hidden Cash is fresh in people’s minds, and that may not be for too long…

All the news from the exit games

7segmentsIn some browsers, the up- and down- arrows above will take you from zero to twelve and back…

Here’s a quick round-up of exit game news:

  • Escape in Edinburgh are holding their “The Escape Games” promotion between Friday (er, tomorrow) and Sunday. Teams of 3 or 4 can pay just £30/team (half price!) to try to escape either of the two identically-dressed rooms. The fastest teams win free games plus T-shirts or mouse mats.
  • Whether you win or not, Escape have posted a teaser for their Dark Room set to open soon, with another message suggesting there may be a prison theme.
  • In other “new room” news, Breakout Manchester (who are struggling with their web site right now, but are taking bookings by e-mail) posted a tweet saying that they will open their second room, Virus, from Friday 6th June. Looking forward to catching the bug!
  • Escap3d of Belfast say that “Our Great Challenge is back! If you get through the puzzles with your own work and open the door within the allocated 60 minutes, you can invite a team of friends for free or we pay you back the admission.” Sounds like exactly the right sort of fighting talk aimed towards purists with a no-clue disposition.
  • Clue HQ of Warrington have posted rather a fun teaser video, an early construction photo and job ads. The site says “We’re currently gearing up for opening towards the end of June 2014” so not long to wait now.
  • The site has previously pointed to discussion of exit games on episode 41 of the The Cultures podcast; the topic is discussed again at the start of the new episode 45 as another member of the team tries a game and reports their experiences. I won’t spoil whether they had a good time or not but you can guess!

DASH 6 by the numbers

DASH logoPlease find below an updated version of a table which details the number of teams on the scoreboard for each city in each edition of the DASH puzzle hunt to date.

Location DASH 1 DASH 2 DASH 3 DASH 4 DASH 5 DASH 6
Albuquerque, NM – – – 6 6+1 3+2+0
Austin, TX – 2 11 12 13+4 10+4+0
Bay Area, CA Y(SF)
Y(PA)
7(SR)
59(LA)
16(SR)
74(SM)
73(SF) 34+7(SF)
32+3(HMB)
53+17+0(SF)
39+5+0(C)
Boston, MA Y 18 26 29 27+2 30+7+1
Chicago, IL – – 17 14 10+1 15+9+0
Davis, CA – 16 15 16 13+7 8+7+1
Houston, TX Y – – – – –
London, UK – – – – 6+2 8+13+0
Los Angeles, CA Y 7 22 21 15+4 15+2+0
(Pasadena)
Minneapolis, MN – – – – 8+7 7+4+0
(recast)
New York, NY – 12 24 25 30+7 26+15+2
Portland, OR Y 6 17 19 19+2 11+7+0
San Diego, CA – – 7 – – –
Seattle, WA Y 32 47 49 49+2 58+4+2
South Bend, IN – – – 1 – –
St. Louis, MO – – – 2 2+3 –
Washington, DC Y 14 22 33 31+1 27+5+0

Here are my initial thoughts:

1) Errors and omissions excepted, with my apologies in advance. The Minneapolis recast figures come from the organisers by private e-mail.

2) The numbers are drawn from the scoreboards and may not reflect teams that participate but do not make the scoreboard for whatever reason, or other infelicities. DASH 1 does not have a public scoreboard on the web site and thus “Y” represents the hunt having happened there with an unknown number of participants. When there are pluses, the number before the first plus reflects the number of teams on the experienced track, the number after the first plus reflects the number of teams on the “new players” track (DASH 5 and 6), and the number after the second plus reflects the number of teams on the junior track (DASH 6).

3) Interpret “Bay Area, CA” using the following key: SF = San Francisco (1, 4, 5, 6), PA = Palo Alto (1), SR = Santa Rosa (2,3), LA = Los Altos (2), SM = San Mateo (3), HMB = Half Moon Bay (5), C = Cupertino (6). I apologise if some of those locations are not really in the Bay Area. (If you tell me that I am a bad person for jumbling Santa Rosa in with the others, I’d believe you.)

4) It’s not a competition to see whose DASH can be the largest; all DASH organiser teams are glorious, generous paragons of virtue, whether their event had one team or 70+, and the community at large thanks them all for the time and effort that they put in.

5) I think it’s fair to say that DASH 6 was a little troubled, with both Seattle and Portland briefly removed from the list of participating cities; thankfully, both cities eventually found local Game Control teams, and I’m sure everyone is particularly grateful there. There was discussion of locations in Phoenix, AZ and Pittsburgh, PA, but sadly neither came to fruition; thanks to people who put in the effort there, all the same.

6) Again, it probably reflects well on the decision to have parallel “experienced” and “newcomer” tracks at DASH 5 and DASH 6 that every city had at least one team playing each track. Indeed, the number of teams on the “new players” track rose from 53 to 101, further justifying its purpose. The junior track may take a little longer to gain traction.

7) I’m in two minds about the Minneapolis recast. The more people who get to join in the DASH fun, the better, but the three-week gap between the first run and the recast means that a lot of the momentum has been lost before people can talk about it, so there hasn’t been nearly as much buzz about a tremendous event as there might have been. (Us UK solvers can talk, given that we held discussion of DASH 5 back a week last year, so perhaps the point of comparison would have to be DASHes 4 and earlier.)

8) There are definitely several other countries to which DASH might expand in the future: given that Sydney and Melbourne have famous and popular puzzle hunts, there’s no reason why there couldn’t be DASH locations there. Closer to the US, Snoutcast recently had Stacy Costa from the University of Toronto, so clearly there is puzzle interest in Canada. Every other English-speaking country is a possibility; maybe even non-Anglophone major world cities with significant expat communities could host DASH some day.

UK puzzle contest history

Mixed US and UK flagYesterday, this site discussed the upcoming UK Puzzle Championship, which starts at midday (UK time) today and runs through to the end of Monday. Looking further around the UK Puzzle Association site – and then going a little further and looking “underneath the hood” – there is (apparently an early version of) a UK puzzling “Hall of Fame” page, which is a lovely piece of work.

There are two areas to focus on: first, mention of the results of the past three years of the UK Puzzle Championship. James McGowan won the first two in 2011 and 2012, with Neil Zussman pipping him by 26 puzzles to 25 in 2013. (Neil also had the distinction of being the top global solver out of the 164 entrants from around the world, taking some extremely accomplished names with his accuracy and speed.) Secondly, the chart of UK team members at the World Puzzle Championships is extremely interesting. It still needs a little interpretation; for instance, I am listed with a position in 2004 despite being a non-playing captain, earning my position for solving on a United Nations team – but, on the other hand, that Guardian article I linked to yesterday reminded me that Nick Gardner was captain in 2006 and is yet not listed.

Nevertheless, we can use this to create an all-time A-team appearance table for UK team members. (This does give credit for appearances in 2002, where there were two UK team members attending but no UK A-team as such.) Credit, also, to Tim Peeters’ site for information about the UK team in 1996.

Six appearances: Nick Deller
Five appearances: Nick Gardner, David McNeill
Four appearances: Ken Wilshire
Three appearances: Simon Anthony, Steven Barge, Tom Collyer, Alan O’Donnell, Liane Robinson, Ronald Stewart, Neil Zussman
Two appearances: Chris Dickson, James McGowan, Gareth Moore
One appearance: George Danker, Meriel Lewis, Stuart Madison, Thomas Powell, Nick Savage, Lionel Wright, Chris Yates

We can also put together some stats about UK participation in the US Puzzle Championships, with a counterpart hall of fame as to which UK participants were highest-placed each year:

2014: Adam Bissett (6 participants)
2013: James McGowan (12 participants)
2012: Neil Zussman (22 participants)
2011: David McNeill (24 participants)
2010: Steven Barge (13 participants)
2009: Steven Barge (13 participants)
2008: Steven Barge (20 participants)
2007: Michael Collins and Nick Gardner (12+ participants)
2006: Steven Barge (26 participants)
2005: David McNeill (12 participants)
2004: David McNeill (6 participants)
2003: Luke Pebody (12 participants)
2002: Nick Gardner (4 participants)
2001: David McNeill (6 participants)
2000: Lionel Wright (6 participants) (courtesy of e-mail from Michael Curl of thinks.com)

A sharp fall in UK participation in the US Puzzle Championships in recent years, but this can be explained in part by the rise in emphasis on the UK Puzzle Championships, the USPC’s fixed timeslot, the shift in selection practices for the UK team for the World Puzzle Championship and a fall in the global participation in the US Puzzle Championships. Another interpretation is that there are dozens and dozens of past UK puzzle championship participants who have been lost to time; surely a challenge for the UK infrastructure is to get them involved once again.

UK Puzzle Championship this weekend

UK Puzzle Association logoGrief, there are a lot of online puzzle culture-free language-neutral contests all happening this weekend. (Next weekend looks almost totally bare by comparison!)

The highlight is undoubtedly the 2½-hour UK Puzzle Championship; start at any point after midday on Friday, so long as you finish by the end of Monday. As you’d expect for a UK tournament, these are based on the UK time zone. Score as many points as possible by answering some or all of the 26 puzzles. The instruction booklet is available so you can see what sorts of puzzles you’ll be asked in advance; perhaps there’s something of a focus on number puzzles, word puzzles and loop puzzles.

The UK Puzzle Championship is definitely deliberately at the accessible end of the long-form puzzle contest tradition – and 17 of the 26 puzzles are relatively low in tariff, so even relatively moderate solvers may well find good opportunities to surprise themselves that they really are able to solve puzzles that looked impossible at first site. More advanced competitors are requested to identify themselves for possible selection for the UK team in the World Puzzle Championship, this year held in mid-August in Croydon. (Recently, the report in the Guardian from the 2006 World Puzzle Championship turned back up again – broadly, good stuff, all round.)

The UK are also holding their 1½-hour round of the World Puzzle Federation Grand Prix this weekend on a similar timescale. This has 15 puzzles, the first 10 of which are reasonably familiar formats and the last five look slightly more unusual. There are two particularly high-value puzzles in the fifteen, so going for either of them would pose a rather high-variance strategy.

As well as the UK holding their annual Puzzle Championship, this weekend also sees India do the same thing. It too is the standard 2½-hour national championship length; while Indian solvers have very little leeway in their timing, global solvers have all weekend to choose their 150-minute solving window. There are 35 puzzles here, though slightly fewer different types. James McGowan has set some of the puzzles here, and also for the UK round of the WPF GP, both of which bode well.

Lastly, if you’re up between 6am and 8am UK time on Saturday 24th, there’s the 2-hour Japanese Puzzle Championship, whose 25-puzzle instruction booklet is something of a work of art in interesting variants. Unusually, the 10th, 20th, 30th, 40th… and so on finishers each win an official T-shirt, which is cute!

All of these are free to play and open to solvers all around the world. Enjoy!

Breakout Manchester

Breakout Manchester logoManchester is set to join London and Bristol as a city with two different exit game sites with the launch of Breakout Manchester. The web site’s “Rooms” page suggests that the first room opened on Saturday 17th May, which seems to be as convincing a claim for an opening date as any, especially as one of their Tweets suggests that they had their first team win on Sunday 18th May. The site’s booking system suggests that bookings are available from Tuesday 20th May onwards; there’s a phone number quoted on the site if you wanted to confirm a booking for the very near future. The off-peak price is particularly attractive.

The site has a really exciting web presence, suggesting that while only one game is open at the moment, there are plans to add three more. I especially like the look of the second game, set to open in June, entitled Madchester. The description reads:

Manchester is famous for many things: football, relentless rain, musicians and bands such as the Smiths, Stone Roses and Oasis, Coronation Street, incredible night clubs such as the Hacienda, The Warehouse Project and Sankeys and artists such as LS Lowry. But what links all these things? What is Manchester trying to hide? This room may reveal the truth….

This sounds like a really distinctive and exciting prospect; the concept of trying to incorporate some local flavour into an exit room would provide a reason to travel from afar to play, and Manchester has more flavour to draw from than most locations. It’s not clear whether the game will be about the 24 Hour Party People sort of Madchester, but the prospect of it makes you want to step on to this one so you can have your melon twisted.

Unusually, there is one factor which might, under certain circumstances, make you want to hold off playing until the second room opens. The first room is John Monroe’s Detective Office, and it’s the same room that Mazebase have already installed at HintHunt in London and at Puzzlair in Bristol. If you’ve played it at either of those locations, you might well not be nearly as surprised by it in Manchester. However, both of these are quite a hike from Manchester; if you haven’t played it before, it’s a great game and you’re in for a treat.

Private e-mail discussion suggests that the proprietors have investigated and plenty of the other UK sites, which breeds confidence. Time will tell if the proprietors have learnt from their extensive research and are able to put the theory into practice for their original rooms; more news about these additional rooms as it becomes available.

Approaches to difficulty in exit games

GameCamp logoYesterday, at GameCamp in London, there was a talk on the exit game phenomenon given by Adrian Hon. It’s not clear what GameCamp etiquette is, whether what gets said at GameCamp stays at GameCamp, whether things can be reported under the Chatham House Rule, or whether there can be wider reports, but it would be great to hear more from the event. Failing that, Adrian discussed the genre towards the end of episode 41 of “The Cultures” podcast.

Some exit games take the approach that they will be very generous with the distribution of hints to their players, even making it clear that this is the policy right at the outset, in the discussion before players enter the room. As this was the approach taken by the first exit room site to open in the UK, this may well be the dominant approach nationally.

By contrast, there are other sites which offer some games where few or no clues are offered. The pitfall there is either that you set the difficulty level relatively high and have no or very few people crack the room, or you set the difficulty level relatively low and risk having people finish the game in less than half the permitted time, which can be something of a flat ending. There are plenty of other solutions, especially if players are prepared to enjoy the possibility of partial credit for solving some, but not all, of the game, but these appear to be less frequent.

Incidentally, the “deliberately very few winners” approach is the one taken by many of the games offered by SCRAP, considered the originators of the genre, among other operators. Befitting the Japanese origins of the “Nintendo hard” stereotype, as an example, their “What is the Real Escape Game?” page talks of a 2% success rate, and their Flickr photostream has a couple of photos of ongoing scoreboards suggesting victory rates not much higher than that. (Anecdotally, more recent games suggest an easing of standards to around 10%.) This site is not yet aware of any UK exit games that take quite such an extreme approach.

The issue of difficulty of exit games is an open one; there appears not to be a consensus on a single correct approach. As different players want to face different challenges, this variety of approaches may well be a good thing for the world. The difficulty is to match potential players up to the right game for them. This web site will do whatever it can to help in this regard.

The Keyhunter site in Birmingham takes a particularly interesting approach in this regard; it advertises its three games as having different levels of difficulty, and advertises its teams successes on social media not only in terms of the time they took but also by how many clues were needed. If you want the added challenge of completing an exit room and having “with 0 hints used” decorating your performance, perhaps Keyhunter might be the right site for you. There may well be other games that offer the same option and this site will make it clear when it’s available.

Weekend round-up

US Sudoku Team logoTechnically this is the US Sudoku Championship logo rather than the US Puzzle Championship one, but it’s always been a beauty. This weekend’s highlight is the US Puzzle Championship, a 2½-hour online language-free culture-neutral puzzle contest, where participation is open to entrants around the world. You can still register to take part; once you’ve logged in, the instruction booklet is available. Download the puzzles in advance; the password will be revealed at 6pm UK time on Saturday 17th and you have until 8:30pm UK time to submit your answers in order to score as many points as possible.

It’s worth reflecting at this point that as recently as 2010, the UK puzzle season was the US Puzzle Championship – and, if you didn’t qualify for the World Championship, that was it. 2010 was a pivotal year with the launch of the UK Puzzle Association and also Logic Masters India bringing frequent tests; 2011 saw the start of the UK Puzzle Championship and so much has followed since. The US Puzzle Championship is quite a traditional event, what with its fixed timeslot; it is clearly aimed to find the best competitors for the phenomenally successful US team for the WPC and sets its difficulty accordingly. If you’d like to know more, this site recommends Dr. Thomas Snyder’s nine-part Better Know the USPC series from 2011.

Let’s round up the latest exit game news as well:

  • In Edinburgh, Escape opened today, and this site has the joy of turning their red “opening soon!” map dot to a glorious yellow.
  • In Manchester, Make A Break have announced good news: they have proved popular enough to extend their opening hours at weekends.
  • In London, HintHunt also have good news to announce: they are opening a second Zen Room from 1st June; they will be able to host five games at once, making them the biggest single site at the moment. They are fully booked up at weekends until mid-July, other than for this second Zen Room, so this is a very rare weekend opportunity to play.
  • However, unfortunately, it’s not all good news; Escape Hunt have announced that their London opening will be delayed until late August. Good things come to those who wait!

Opening in Leeds on Monday: Tick Tock Unlock

"Tick Tock Unlock" logoThis site has previously featured a preview of Tick Tock Unlock, an exit game coming to Leeds very soon. Their Facebook site suggests that a booking has already been made for May 19th, and the opening date has been confirmed on Twitter, which is sufficiently convincing to merit a place on The Timeline and the exit game details page. However, the web site suggests that bookings are currently available from Wednesday 21st May onwards, so it may well be that they have plans for the rest of Monday and Tuesday.

There have been some gorgeous photos added to their Facebook site recently; it’s well worth clicking through to see the rest of the album. The details within the room look atmospheric and delightful. The photos say that “You can step into the professor’s office but the leaving will not be so easy…” Private e-mail reveals a little more that can be exclusively revealed. The game is entitled Blueprint and here’s its background:

“Conspiracy theorist and history professor, James Watson, has vanished under mysterious circumstances. He was once considered the bright star of academia before he uncovered the web of criminal reality lurking in plain sight. What started as a drive to unmask the criminals very quickly took over his life. His obsession, which led many to call him delusional, consumed him; some even questioned his sanity. That is, until he vanished without a trace. If you are reading this, you already know too much and they are coming after you next.

You are the last remaining hope to uncover the truth from his delusions. Solve the mystery, escape in sixty minutes – Tick Tock Unlock.”

Extremely promising and tantalisingly close!