ClueKeeper

ClueKeeper logoClueKeeper describes itself as “a platform for developing and playing location-based clue hunts”. It was used at every location in DASH 6, which counts as pretty extensive testing, and may well be used in plenty of in-person puzzle hunts in the future. However, it can also be used for self-guided hunts, whether you’re exploring a new city, or trying to get a new insight on a city you already know.

Ravenchase and Shinteki, both known for their corporate and public puzzle hunts on the East and West coasts of the US respectively, have each created four self-guided hunts with the system in cities across the US. There haven’t been any created in the UK yet, but searching for treasure hunt uk in the search engine of your choice reveals there are rather more companies than you might have guessed who are willing to sell you exactly such self-guided hunts in locations across the UK.

This site hasn’t got the experience to comment on them and wouldn’t pick a favourite in any instance, but notes that Wildgoose Events offer tablet treasure hunts, supplying a tablet with a preloaded app to teams. It would be interesting to compare the functionality and flexibility of Wildgoose Events‘ app with that offered by ClueKeeper. There may well be a natural synergy to be exploited between any of the several self-guided hunt companies in the UK and ClueKeeper at some point down the line.

Perceived reception of ClueKeeper from DASH participants was generally positive and largely very positive, though not without a few issues which broadly proved reasonably easy to rectify. There also have been reports of a couple of issues relating to a confusion between the different levels of difficulty at which the hunt was offered, possibly caused (or made worse) by the implementation of DASH within ClueKeeper. People enjoyed having the ability to see the results soon after the hunt concluded, the awarding of encouragement and partial credit for partial answers, and the standardisation of the experience from team to team. It may well be that it takes a system like ClueKeeper in practice to be able to run a hunt with more than a few dozen teams playing at once.

During DASH 6, ClueKeeper had a system where some hints were awarded to teams after specific lengths of time. This may have divided opinion a little more, though at a guess more were in favour than against; some teams were disappointed when hints arrived and reflected a level of progress they had already reached, but that’s more of a feature than a bug and it’s always possible to pay points to receive later clues “ahead of time”. The issue of hinting within puzzle hunts will always be somewhat controversial, and perhaps it’s a good thing for the world that a variety of approaches exist and the challenge for hunts is to set people’s expectations appropriately and help people choose the event which best matches their expectations.

It’s also possible to take a sour perspective of ClueKeeper’s business model, predicated on a perspective of puzzle hunts being strictly amateur labours of love, or to criticise it for the relatively recent operating system requirements, or to blanche at the use within the app of external services from a partner considered controversial by some. With this in mind, it may be wise to consider ClueKeeper one possible tool for puzzle hunt administration and emphasise that it’s just as possible as it ever was to run, or play in, a hunt which doesn’t use it. However, it’s a powerful tool within its own frame of reference and it already enables an admirable range of possibilities. This site looks forward to seeing it develop further over time and to using it to play further hunts.

(Right of reply is available to the ClueKeeper team if they’d like it, though hopefully the difference is clear between this site expressing an opinion and this site reporting on opinions.)

Introducing the Timeline


This site is pleased to present the Timeline, a sourced attempt to track the chronological progression of exit room openings and closures in the UK and Ireland. It covers the past and the present of exit rooms, so let’s look to the future and see which sites are likely to be next to be added to the Timeline. There was a big rush of openings around December 2013, give or take a month; there may well be another big rush of openings coming soon.

  • Tick Tock Unlock in Leeds has probably got to be considered the favourite to be next to be added to the Timeline. The first date on which books available has been pushed back at least twice, from April 29th to May 12th to the current date of May 19th, but the social media campaign remains active. Perhaps this could be interpreted as a sign of the site being very close to opening.
  • Can’t see anything on the Cipher web site or social media about when they are due to reopen for their second season, but the suggestion is that bookings are not being taken only for May. Fingers crossed that a reopening may only be a few weeks away.
  • Not much obviously happening around Escape Live in Birmingham, but the team may well be hard at work on the physical site and they may well hit their June target.
  • Likewise, our coverage of Clue HQ in Warrington was only very recent. The web site continues to be updated and suggests an opening date of late June.
  • The Escape Hunt London site has nothing obviously new – most notably, still no location yet, which points to the previous estimate of “June or July” remaining active. A little searching through Facebook and LinkedIn reveals the addition of the London branch’s Facebook page. Seven five-star reviews before the site has opened is a little cheeky.
  • The Can You Escape? Indiegogo for a site in Edinburgh has gone a little quiet, but this site remains on the case and the campaign mentions plans in case the Indiegogo does not reach its target, so nothing too worrying there.
  • Moving towards the back burner, the silence from QuestRoom of London is possibly bigger cause for concern; still nothing from the long-term hope at Live Escape Game of Brighton and Puzzlescape is now getting quite cold.

Coming up later this year: Autumn

Autumn logoAs the second part of this two-part feature, here are the events that have recently reached us which are set to take place later on in the year:

August 3: ‘Top Secret’ One Day Cryptic Treasure Hunt, in-person, Essex
August 22: Mind Sports Olympiad KenKen and Sudoku puzzle contest, in-person, London
September 6: save the date
September 13: Armchair Treasure Hunting Day, in-person, Oakham

This site has discussed the “Top Secret” hunt in Essex in August previously, but some more information has been revealed: The event will be team based, with each team consisting of up to six participants. Teams are requested to be there well before the 10:30am start time, for a 6pm finish. The event is described as “similar to ‘escape the room’ events”, except with multiple rooms; many of the rooms will contain mechanical and physical puzzles, codes and riddles that need to be solved in order to reveal an escape route that the teams can use, but there’ll still be more to do even after escape. The planned treasure should deliver a haul of limited edition puzzles valued at £300 to each member of the winning team. I would expect the event to be particularly heavy on physical puzzles; if you want practice with them, the 15th Midlands Puzzle Party will happen on June 15th, and you can read an archive of reports from past events.

The team behind “Top Secret” claim responsibility for three past Armchair Treasure Hunt club events, and a date has been announced for the next one: September 13th. The announcement makes it clear that non-members are welcome along with club members. The event will be taking place in Oakham, in the traditional county of Rutland – or the East Midlands to the rest of us. I have heard rumour of something happening on September 6th, rumour which might never be mentioned again if nothing comes of it, so the week of the 6th to the 13th might be a big one, not least because of Puzzled Pint in the middle of it!

Coming up later this year: Spring

Spring logo(If you’re following a feed, you may recently have seen an early version of a future article posted in error that I have not been able to recall. Please ignore it, and sorry for the confusion.)

News has reached the site of events coming up later in the year: there’s enough to justify a two-part feature. First, the events coming up sooner rather than later.

Spring has become online puzzle contest season, for May is fully loaded with them:

May 9-12: WPF Sudoku Grand Prix round 5: Japan, online
May 9-12: UK Sudoku Championship, online
May 17: US Puzzle Championship, online
May 23-26: WPF Puzzle Grand Prix round 5: United Kingdom, online
May 23-26: UK Puzzle Championship, online

It doesn’t matter where in the world you are, you’re welcome to participate in all of the above. There is a particular initiative for UK participants, though; the top two participants in the UK Sudoku Championship will earn places in the UK team at the World Sudoku Championship, which will be in Croydon this year between the 10th and 17th of August. It’s likely, though not yet confirmed, that one or two places for the UK team for the World Puzzle Championship will similarly be awarded to top UK performers in the UK Puzzle Championship.

The instruction booklet for next weekend’s UK Sudoku Championship has been published; it’s a two-hour contest. The two WPF Grand Prix events are 90-minute contests, and the UK and US Puzzle Championships are traditionally two-and-a-half hour events, and likely to be two of the most interesting online puzzle contests of the year.

If you’re a real World Championship contender, you might want to take part in 3½-4 hours’ worth of puzzle contests in a single day, as practice for the real event (though both world championships tend to feature many, shorter, rounds, rather than two very long rounds). As for the rest of us… I tried it once, and consider it to be for the hardcore only!

The Australian puzzle hunt tradition

Australian flagNews has reached the site, over time, of three puzzle hunts all set within Australia. All three are primarily organised over the Internet and all three welcome online participants from around the world.

The oldest of the three is the Melbourne University Mathematics and Statistics Society’s Puzzle Hunt, hereafter the MUMS hunt, which has archives dating back to its first year in 2004. A little younger, since 2007, is the CISRA hunt, where CISRA stands for Canon Information Systems Research Australia who promote it, and the archives of the University of Sydney’s counterpart SUMS puzzle hunt date back to 2009. All three have some similarities in format, to the point where it may be useful to consider them (slight variants of) a conventional Australian format.

The Australian format generally has five rounds (known as Acts or Groups) of puzzles leading up to a single metapuzzle relying on all the previous answers. On the first day of the hunt, the first round of (normally four, though sometimes five for CISRA) puzzles is released, and each puzzle can be solved for five points. On the second day, the second round of puzzles is released, along with the first hint for each puzzle in the first round. Each second round puzzle can be solved for five points, but the value of the first round puzzles drops to four points. Similarly, on the third day, a third round of puzzles is released, valued at five points each, along with first hints for the second round of puzzles, now valued at four points each, and with second hints for the first round of puzzles, with a value that drops to three points each.

Day four sees a fourth round of puzzles and extra hints for each of the previous three rounds, and day five sees a fifth round of puzzles and hints similarly. (Each round has a maximum of three sets of hints, and a minimum value of two points per puzzle.) You’ll generally need (almost?) all the puzzles’ solutions to be able to solve the metapuzzle, and the MUMS hunt has a physically hidden object to find as a result of it. That’s the only extent to which a physical presence is required.

The MUMS hunt welcomes teams of up to ten solvers, SUMS limits teams to five and CISRA limits teams to four. I recognise some crossover between the top teams in the MUMS hunt and the top participants in some of the other great online hunts from around the world, though the names are not always the same.

More excitingly, I think I recognise some team names as having UK members; the ManMaths team has Manchester solvers, including the team behind the wonderful Puzzlebomb. Likewise, I get the impression that the PuzzleBrains team may come from the forum, and a little investigation into team “Fifty-Nine Degrees North” points to solvers on Orkney. So a great deal of UK interest, and I’m sure there must be other UK solvers I don’t know about. Good luck to you all, especially in the next MUMS hunt, which starts on Monday 5th May!

Coming soon to Warrington: Clue HQ

"Clue HQ" logoThe process of finding new exit games before they open involves a lot of searching for carefully selected search terms, plus town names. Clearly it’s worth searching for the biggest cities and towns in the UK first; Liverpool is a big market which doesn’t have a site yet. Siting a game in Warrington might be even smarter still, as it’s within twenty miles of both Liverpool and Manchester.

Clue HQ have announced their location in Warrington. It’s extremely close to both Warrington Central train station and Warrington’s bus station. They have also posted a design video suggesting that they, like Escape Live (still under construction in Birmingham), have posted an address suggesting a venue underneath railway arches. Clue HQ have posted a design video showing their plans; ((Edited to add: it’s now been removed!)) while the arrangement of rooms inside the site looks intricate and suggests a great deal to explore, the video may well be indicative rather than to be taken literally as a spoiler.

Not much else is known; no opening date and no prices yet, though they have set up the site’s Facebook page and the site’s Twitter account, and the web site is very smart. The site is set up for teams of three to six and recommends a team of four.

Another very promising-looking site. Fingers crossed that there is more to say about Clue HQ before long; expect to read it here when the news becomes available.

The League Table

Picture of a generic trophyThis is the first installment of an occasional feature to act as a status report on the exit games in the UK. On its own it means little, but repeated sufficiently many times it could be the basis of a survey of growth over time.

Exit Game sites known to have opened in the UK/Ireland: 9/1
Exit Game sites known to be open in the UK/Ireland: 8/1
Exit Game sites known to have closed temporarily in the UK/Ireland: 1/0
Exit Game sites known to have closed permanently in the UK/Ireland: 0/0
Exit Game sites known to be under construction in the UK/Ireland: 3/0
Exit Game sites less confidently known to be under construction in the UK/Ireland: 3/0

Site name Number of exit rooms Number of different games Number of TripAdvisor reviews Number of 5/5 TripAdvisor reviews Local TripAdvisor ranking
clueQuest 3 2 358 347 1
Cipher 1 1 – – –
Cryptopia 1 1 20 17 3
ESCAP3D 1 1 64 57 2
Ex(c)iting Game 2 2 12 8 28
HintHunt 4 2 767 714 3
Keyhunter 3 3 34 25 6
Make A Break 1 1 15 11 12
Puzzlair 2 2 29 29 2
XIT 4 4 2 1 139

This needs to be taken with a heavy pinch of salt. This site supports all the exit games that exist and will not make claims that any particular one is superior to any other particular one. Please note that the TripAdvisor rankings represent a wide variety of locations and cannot be directly compared against each other. In fact, it’s probably pushing it even to compare the tripAdvisor rankings of two exit game sites in the same city.

The lesson to be drawn here is how popular all the different exit games around the UK and Ireland are, and how even the least well-reviewed (so far!) of them have a record of success of which many other attractions would be jealous.

Act fast! Lord Fear’s Midnight Hunt

Knightmare helmetReaders of a certain age will recognise the picture at once as the iconic Helmet of Justice from the legendary UK puzzle show Knightmare, a staple of ITV during the late 1980s and early 1990s. The show overtly featured riddles and transportation puzzles; even navigating the real human player around the computer graphical dungeons could be a puzzle in itself. Changes in TV channel demographics meant there wasn’t a place for the show from the mid-’90s, but it remains fondly remembered, with knightmare.com probably the hub of the fandom, and repeats still stand the test of time better than many other shows celebrating their silver anniversary, even if partly as a period piece.

The show has come back into the public consciousness over the last year or two, most notably with a Knightmare Live theatre game show that proved popular at the Edinburgh Comedy Festival in 2013 and has been touring successfully ever since. There was also a one-off revival as part of YouTube’s Geek Week, and a convention, set to take place in Norwich, where the show was originally filmed, on Friday 9th May to Sunday 11th May. Saturday and Sunday night sees a convention expected to attract some of the original actors and offering teams a chance to play a single room of the dungeon. The Friday night will feature the Knightmare Live stage show, and I can imagine no better company in which to see the show.

This is exciting enough to merit discussion in the context of a beloved puzzle show alone, but even more exciting still is mention of Lord Fear’s Midnight Hunt running from 11:30pm on the Saturday night until 3am (!!) on Sunday morning.

“Come join us for an exclusive opportunity to be chased around the the streets of Norwich by Mark Knight, a.k.a Lord Fear himself! You will be joining a team of ten others as you all search through Norwich City Centre for clues to save both yourself and your team from Lord Fear as he attempts to hunt you down. […] The hunt will last for at least a couple of hours – please note that there will be a lot of movement on foot (walking, running etc) involved.”

I’m not sure to what extent the hunt will attempt to recapture and celebrate the puzzle content of the show, but it sounds like a spectacular, possibly unique, opportunity all the same – and with only one team of ten players getting to play, you might well think it worth taking a chance on a £20 ticket for the hunt; con tickets are not too dear either. Sadly I won’t be able to attend the weekend, but I’d love to hear reports from the convention, and possibly even its hunt, from any attendees.

Can You Escape?

"Can You Escape?" logoEdinburgh is a very rich city and an obvious gap in the market for exit games, so I’m delighted but not at all surprised to see this Indiegogo project for Can You Escape?, a proposed exit game for the city. The video is tastefully done and the social media campaign backing the Indiegogo project got off to a vibrant start, all of which are excellent signs. The figures in the business plan section look reasonably convincing and it does look like there has been a great deal of thought put into the project, though the numbers make it very clear that this is an industry where nobody gets rich. (Edinburgh’s definitely got about as good a chance as any, though.)

It’s a “flexible funding” project, so if you make a pledge, you will be charged whether the project reaches the goal or not and the money (minus moderately hefty Indiegogo fees) will reach the people behind the project – and there’s always the possibility that the project won’t make it all the way. (The QuestRoom Indiegogo didn’t get too far, but I hope that they find their way to London before long.) The prices look reasonably comparable to those of exit games around the country, though, so this is really just pre-ordering a ticket. The people responsible are very clear about who they are, so you can get in touch and make your own investigations in order to decide whether to pre-order or not. If you really back their vision, their VIP pass for one play in each new room they design might prove a great investment. Best of luck to Alastair and Lauren and hopefully there will be more to report from them soon.

In other exit game news, I’ve long enjoyed a podcast called The Cultures; it’s not a games podcast as such, but the people behind it have worked (together and separately) on games projects, on and off, for years. The most recent episode (download episode 41) has a lovely ten-minute piece on exit games at the end, comparing experiences at HintHunt in London with those at Claustrophilia in Budapest, and discussing the genre’s UK predecessors. Co-host Andrea Phillips also appears on the most recent episode of the wonderful Snoutcast podcast, discussing her ARG and other transmedia work alongside much of her other involvement with games.

What’s next in the UK after DASH 6?

calendar iconSo you had a fantastic time at DASH 6, are suffering a bad comedown and are wondering what’s next, knowing that you don’t want to have to wait a whole year until the next one. (OK, I wrote “you” when I’m really referring to myself, but I don’t think I’m the only one.) So what’s happening before then?

Nothing’s quite like DASH, but there are interesting things going on. Nothing has quite the full package, but there are things that can scratch some of the itches.

If you’re in London and want a murder mystery game that will lead teams around London looking for clues and meeting characters, you don’t have long to wait at all: a door in a wall‘s The Diplomatic Corpse will run every evening and some afternoons from 2nd May to 15th June. If you’re in Wrexham rather than London, there’s Silent State, “a roaming theatre game […] a mixture of puzzles, music, intrigue and theatrical happenings“, happening three times on 10th May.

If you want a full in-person hunt, there will be a Treasure Hunt at the Manorcon board games convention in Leicester on 20th July, and also a One Day Cryptic Treasure Hunt in Essex on 3rd August. The latter event sounds really exciting, though it comes from a different tradition of Armchair Treasure Hunts rather than DASH-style puzzle hunts; if the principle sounds good, you’ll likely really enjoy this write-up of an event by the same team in 2011 that illustrates what the puzzles may be like. If that sounds good, line your team up and sign up soon!

That’s not your only option, though; if you’re interested in playing an online puzzle hunt as well as an in-person one, the Melbourne University Mathematics and Statistics Society’s annual puzzle hunt runs from 5th to 9th May. This traditionally features puzzles of a variety of difficulties from a moderate team difficulty to a very high ceiling indeed, but is one of the world’s great hunts with a ten-year tradition behind it.

If you want logic puzzles, more like puzzle 3 from this DASH than anything else, there are plenty of options. The World Puzzle Federation’s Puzzle GP tournaments happen once every four weeks; in fact, there’s one in progress right now, so clear a 90-minute schedule to finish before 11pm on Monday night. A longer challenge is the 2½-hour US Puzzle Championship on 17th May.

If you want to see (at least some of!) the people who turned up at DASH, many of them play at, or run, Puzzled Pint in London on the second Tuesday of every month. The style of the puzzles bears some similarities to that of DASH, though it’s an evening’s challenge rather than a whole-day event.

All of these events, and more, are listed in the event calendar at this site; when we learn about more events to add, we’ll write about them in our blog, which discusses puzzle events and much more, not least exit games, also known as escape games, locked room games and so on. There are currently eight exit game sites open in the UK and one in Ireland, with one more in the UK currently closed for refurbishment. New sites are opening on a roughly monthly basis at the moment.

So it may be another year until DASH, but there are loads of fun things going on. Keep visiting this site and we’ll share exciting news as we get it!

was a blog about puzzle hunts, puzzle games, escape rooms and more